Customize Obsidian Omnisearch Excerpts For Better Search

Are you an Obsidian user who loves the power of Omnisearch but sometimes finds the search results a bit overwhelming? Do you wish you had more control over the excerpts displayed, especially when the search phrase appears in the file name or when you'd prefer a shorter snippet for better context? This article dives into a feature request aimed at enhancing the Omnisearch experience by giving users more flexibility in how excerpts are displayed. We'll explore the current challenges, the proposed solutions, and why these changes could significantly improve your note-taking workflow.

The Current Excerpt Challenge in Omnisearch

One of the most valuable features of Obsidian Omnisearch is the ability to show excerpts of your search results, which is a key component to understanding the context around your search query. This feature helps you quickly identify the correct document, especially when dealing with numerous files that contain the same search phrase. However, the current implementation presents a few challenges. The default setting displays three lines of context, which, while helpful, can sometimes lead to a cluttered search view, especially when you're dealing with many search results at once. The excerpts can be overwhelming when you're quickly trying to find the right information.

Another issue arises when the search phrase is present in the file name itself. In these cases, the excerpts often display metadata from the frontmatter of the note, such as creation time or other properties. This information is usually not very helpful when you're trying to locate the specific content within the file. For example, imagine searching for "meeting notes" and finding a file named "Meeting Notes - 2024-03-08." The excerpt might show the date or other irrelevant details instead of the actual content you're looking for, making it less efficient.

The limitations of the current excerpt settings can slow down your search process, making it harder to quickly find the information you need. These limitations highlight the need for more customizable options to tailor the search experience to individual preferences and workflows. Addressing these issues can greatly improve the usability of Obsidian Omnisearch, making it a more powerful tool for note-taking and knowledge management. By providing users with more control over how excerpts are displayed, the plugin can become more efficient and user-friendly, catering to a wider range of note-taking styles and preferences. The goal is to allow users to fine-tune their search results to focus on the most relevant information quickly.

Proposed Solutions: Customizing Excerpts

To address the excerpt challenges, the feature request proposes two key solutions, which would greatly enhance the user experience. The first is a switch that allows users to disable excerpts entirely when the search phrase is found in the file name. This would eliminate the display of often irrelevant frontmatter information and provide a cleaner, more focused search view. Imagine searching for a specific term and immediately seeing the content where it appears in the file, without the distraction of metadata.

The second proposed solution is to add a setting that controls the length of the excerpts, allowing users to specify the number of lines displayed. This would enable users to tailor the context to their liking, for example, by reducing the excerpt to a single line. This feature would be especially useful when the search phrase appears in the middle of a sentence, allowing you to see just enough context to quickly understand the meaning. In certain cases, you might prefer a longer excerpt to get a more comprehensive view of the surrounding text. The ability to adjust the excerpt length would provide the flexibility to suit different search scenarios and personal preferences. This level of customization would allow you to optimize your search experience, making it easier to find the information you need, faster. Implementing these options would empower users to create a more efficient and personalized search workflow. By providing these tools, Obsidian Omnisearch would become an even more indispensable tool for anyone who relies on a robust search function to manage their notes and enhance their productivity.

Alternatives Considered and Why They Fall Short

While the current version of Omnisearch offers several settings, they don't fully address the excerpt-related issues. Turning off excerpts completely, for instance, can make it difficult to identify the correct file, especially for shorter or more generic search phrases. Without any context, users might have to open multiple files to find the information they need, wasting time and effort. Simply relying on the file name alone is often not enough to determine the relevance of a document, leading to an inefficient search process. The context provided by excerpts is crucial for quick file identification.

Other settings might offer some control over how search results are displayed, but they don't provide the fine-grained customization proposed in the feature request. The ability to disable excerpts based on the file name and adjust the excerpt length offers a more precise way to manage the information displayed in search results. These specific options would directly address the problems users face with cluttered results and irrelevant metadata. These customizations would streamline the search process and allow users to focus on the content they need without unnecessary distractions. Therefore, the alternatives currently available do not fully meet the needs of users who want greater control over the appearance of their search results. The proposed features would offer a significant improvement over existing options, providing a much-improved user experience.

Additional Context and Benefits

The image provided in the original request clearly illustrates the problem. In the first search result, the excerpt displays file properties, which are not helpful. The second result shows how a single line of context would be sufficient to understand the search phrase's context. Implementing the proposed features would lead to a cleaner, more efficient search experience. Users would be able to quickly identify the relevant files, saving time and improving productivity. By tailoring the excerpt display, users can focus on the content they need without being distracted by irrelevant information. This increased efficiency translates into a more enjoyable note-taking experience, as users spend less time searching and more time creating and using their notes. The ability to customize the search results makes Obsidian Omnisearch a more versatile tool, adaptable to a variety of note-taking styles and workflows. Ultimately, these features would enhance the overall user experience and solidify Obsidian Omnisearch as an essential tool for effective note management.

Conclusion: Embracing Customization for Enhanced Search

The feature request to implement more excerpt options in Obsidian Omnisearch is a valuable suggestion that addresses key pain points in the search experience. By providing the ability to disable excerpts when the search phrase appears in the file name and by allowing users to adjust the excerpt length, Omnisearch would become a more customizable and efficient tool. These changes would lead to a cleaner search view, faster file identification, and a more enjoyable note-taking workflow. The proposed solutions offer a practical way to improve the user experience and make Omnisearch an even more indispensable part of the Obsidian ecosystem.

For more details on Obsidian and its plugins, you can visit the official Obsidian website: Obsidian